• World
    • Africa
    • Asia Pacific
    • Central & South Asia
    • Europe
    • Latin America & Caribbean
    • Middle East & North Africa
    • North America
  • Coronavirus
  • Politics
    • US Election
    • US politics
    • Donald Trump
    • Brexit
    • European Union
    • India
    • Arab world
  • Economics
    • Finance
    • Eurozone
    • International Trade
  • Business
    • Entrepreneurship
    • Startups
    • Technology
  • Culture
    • Entertainment
    • Music
    • Film
    • Books
    • Travel
  • Environment
    • Climate change
    • Smart cities
    • Green Economy
  • Global Change
    • Education
    • Refugee Crisis
    • International Aid
    • Human Rights
  • International Security
    • ISIS
    • War on Terror
    • North Korea
    • Nuclear Weapons
  • Science
    • Health
  • 360 °
  • The Interview
  • In-Depth
  • Insight
  • Quick Read
  • Video
  • Podcasts
  • Interactive
  • My Voice
  • About
  • FO Store
Sections
  • World
  • Coronavirus
  • US Election
  • Politics
  • Economics
  • Business
  • Culture
  • Sign Up
  • Login
  • Publish

Make Sense of the world

Unique insight from 2,000+ contributors in 80+ Countries

Close

The Fallout From Syria: Hate Speech in Indonesia

By Navhat Nuraniyah • Mar 25, 2014

Jihadi groups propagate an anti-Shia narrative to mobilize Indonesian militants to fight in Syria.

A hate speech regulation is desperately needed in Indonesia to contain the damaging effects of jihadi propaganda, as this narrative is increasingly used to mobilize Indonesian Muslims against the Assad regime in Syria. The anti-Shia jihadi propaganda has provoked attacks on Shias in Indonesia and could worsen sectarian tensions if not contained.

Fifty Indonesian fighters are said to have joined jihadi opposition forces in Syria following the anti-Shia propaganda by local jihadi groups, which has played an important role in mobilizing support against Bashar al-Assad.

Anti-Shia Propaganda as Mobilizing Tool

Framing the war in Syria as a sectarian conflict — Muslims vs. non-Muslims — that justifies “jihad” has not come naturally in the Indonesian context. For one, many mainstream Indonesian Muslims still consider Shias as part of Islam. To many of them, fighting the Alawi regime of Assad is like fighting fellow Muslims. (Alawi is an offshoot of Shia Islam.)

Some elements within local jihadi groups argue that the nature of the Syrian conflict is merely political — a civil war rather than a sectarian strife — and thus does not legitimize jihad. They maintain that defending Muslims in Myanmar and Palestine is more important because the sectarian nature of the conflicts is more clear-cut.

To convince the majority Sunni Muslims of the legitimacy of jihad in Syria, jihadi groups propagate the anti-Shia narrative that frames the conflict as a sectarian one. Anti-Shia hate speech and propaganda have been vital for successful mobilization of Indonesian fighters to go to Syria.

Indeed, in the last couple of years, various jihadi media have been flooded with anti-Shia propaganda and hate speech. Articles on the infidelity and cruelty of Shias appear daily on various jihadi websites. In those articles and other publications, the anti-Shia and anti-Assad narratives are usually posted side by side. Images of Sunni Muslim victims of the Syrian conflict are used to reinforce the murderous image of Shias, which all in all, represent a powerful propaganda to mobilize fighters to go to Syria.

The anti-Shia narrative has two core elements. Firstly, it gives theological justification for the war by portraying Shia Islam as a deviant belief, which not only taints the purity of Islam but also is hostile to it. Secondly, it frames the Syrian conflict within a broader sectarian war between Shias and Sunnis. The narrative goes that throughout the history of Islam, the Shias have always tried to subvert the Sunni caliphate.

It also posits that the Syrian conflict is not just a civil war, but rather part of the struggle of international Shia forces — the Assad regime, Iran and Hezbollah — to annihilate the Sunni population and establish a Shia state in the Levant and the Gulf.

One of the most vocal radical clerics who has incited hatred against Shias, Abu Bakar Ba’asyir, dubs the Alawi regime in Syria as “worse than infidels and Jews.” This narrative that demonizes Shias is used as a justification for armed jihad in Syria which, according to Ba’asyir, is currently more urgent than pilgrimage to Mecca.

Another active propagator of the narrative is Hilal Ahmar Society Indonesia (HASI), the humanitarian wing of Jemaah Islamiyah. HASI actively holds public discussions and book launches about Shias and Syria to raise funds for the Syrian cause. Given its humanitarian posture, HASI has been able to target mainstream Muslim groups, including the youth organization of Muhammadiyah. By selling anti-Shia and anti-Assad narratives, HASI has managed to collect a considerable amount of donations that have been used to help Syrian civilians buy support for the jihadi opposition in Syria.

Incitement to Violence Against Shias in Indonesia

While there has been subdued Sunni-Shia tension in Indonesia, the Syrian conflict has made it worse. Violent attacks and harassment against Shias in Indonesia have increased in the past few years. The Abu Umar terrorist cell planned to target Shia figures and institutions in 2011, which failed to materialize.

In 2012, 1,000 Sunni villagers attacked a Shia community in Sampang, Madura Island and in 2013, a Sunni mob attacked a Shia boarding school in Jember, East Java. While not many were killed, several were hurt or displaced.

Despite rising Sunni-Shia tension, anti-Shia hate speech is still allowed to continue. What started out as encouragement to fight pro-Assad forces in Syria has developed into incitement of violence against the local Shia community. Much of the propaganda warns the Sunni majority of what extremists call the unprecedented growth and aggressiveness of Shias in Indonesia.

Most recently, an incitement to attack a Shia religious celebration in Jakarta was spread by the above-ground Majelis Mujahidin Indonesia through jihadi online and social media. It successfully mobilized 200 people to protest, who forcefully halted the event until police quickly intervened.

Need for Hate Speech Law

Most local observers agree that anti-Shia propaganda and hate speech have been largely responsible for both mobilizing Indonesian jihadists to go to Syria and for the alarming growth of Sunni-Shia tension in the country.

Unfortunately, Indonesia does not have any regulation that criminalizes religious hate speech and incitement to violence. There was a proposal to include hate speech in existing counterterrorism law, but it is yet to be accepted. Human rights groups are now counting on the religious harmony bill to address hate speech.

A future hate speech regulation should set a clear and carefully crafted definition of hate speech, so as not to harm freedom of speech. With regard to hate speech online, the law should avoid imposing excessive measures. Banning extremist websites and social media accounts is not only ineffective but also counterproductive as repression could only lead to more radicalization.

Instigators of anti-Shia hate speech should not go unpunished as they are breeding the seeds of sectarian tension. This, combined with the strengthening of jihadi forces following the return of Syrian veterans, might fuel a larger sectarian conflict in years to come.

*[This article was originally published by RSIS.]

The views expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect Fair Observer’s editorial policy.

Image: Copyright © Shutterstock. All Rights Reserved

Share Story
Categories360° Analysis, Asia Pacific, International Security, Middle East & North Africa, Politics TagsAssad, Focus Article, Foreign Fighters in Syria, Indonesia, Islam, Jihad, Jihadists, Navhat Nuraniyah, Pakistan, RSIS, Sectarianism, Shia, Shiite, Sunni, Syria, Syrian Civil War
Join our network of more than 2,000 contributors to publish your perspective, share your story and shape the global conversation. Become a Fair Observer and help us make sense of the world.

READ MORE IN THIS 360° SERIES

The Geopolitics of the Syrian Civil War (Part 2/2)
By Joseph Hughes • Jul 31, 2014
Syria’s Salafi Awakening: Existential Psychological Primers (Part 2/2)
By Zach Goldberg • Jul 31, 2014
The Geopolitics of the Syrian Civil War (Part 1/2)
By Joseph Hughes • Jul 20, 2014
Syria’s Salafi Awakening: Existential Psychological Primers (Part 1/2)
By Zach Goldberg • Jul 15, 2014
The Hezbollah Cavalcade: Iran’s Important Weapon in the Middle East
By Nicholas Heras & Phillip Smyth • Jun 07, 2014
100 Years Later: Lessons for the US in Syria
By Max Reibman • May 21, 2014
France's Gung-Ho Policy in Syria
By Clotilde de Swarte • Mar 28, 2014
Policy From Inside the Perimeter: No Finger in the Wind
By David Holdridge • Mar 12, 2014
Returning From Syria: Terrorism in the West
By Paul Ashley • Mar 01, 2014
The End of a Unified Syria
By Carl Anthony Wege • Sep 04, 2013
Chemical Attacks and Military Interventions
By Omar S. Dahi • Aug 28, 2013
The Alawite Question
By Dina Yazdani • Aug 22, 2013
International Jihad and the Syrian Conflict
By Nicholas Heras & Aaron Zelin • Aug 07, 2013
Syria and the Crumbling Region: A Look at Lebanon
By Helios Global • Jul 17, 2013
The Prevalence of Sectarianism: Hezbollah and the Syrian Civil War
By Josef Olmert • May 27, 2013
Who Will Be Syria's Knight Sans Armor? (Part 1/2)
By Jennifer Helgeson • May 18, 2013
Stop Syria From Becoming an Afghan-Style Disaster
By Dmitri Trenin • Mar 21, 2013
Syria: All the King's Horses...
By David Holdridge • Feb 14, 2013
Syria: Political Dialogue and the Rise of Salafists
By Rajai Masri • Feb 02, 2013
The Middle East in 2013
By Juan Cole • Jan 01, 2013
Will Brahimi Reach a Breakthrough in Syria?
By Vijay Prashad • Dec 30, 2012
Is Chaos in Syria the Way Out?
By Maksymilian Czuperski • Nov 18, 2012
Syria: At the Epicenter of Regional Fault Lines
By Adrian Shahbaz • Jul 23, 2012
Libya to Syria: R2P and the ‘Double Standards’ Issue
By Jean-Baptiste Jeangene Vilmer • Jul 23, 2012
Russia Supports Syria For Old Times’ Sake
By Anna Pivovarchuk • Jul 10, 2012
Assad at the Tipping Point
By Jeffrey Laurenti • Jun 10, 2012
Don't Despair on Annan’s Syria Plan, Yet
By Jeffrey Laurenti • Apr 24, 2012
Annan Plan Up Against the Syrian Wall
By Jeffrey Laurenti • Apr 10, 2012
The Revolution Will Be Uploaded: Citizen Journalism in Homs
By Nicholas Heras • Mar 04, 2012
Adding Fuel to Syria's Fire
By Foreign Policy in Focus • Feb 16, 2012
Russia’s Hard-Nosed Realism in Syria: The Roots and Reasoning
By Gordon Hahn • Feb 16, 2012
The UN's Return on Syria
By Jeffrey Laurenti • Feb 15, 2012
Is Assad’s Syria ‘Too Important to Fail’ for the Resistance Axis?
By Kevjn Lim • Feb 13, 2012
A Test of Wills: The Arab League Asserts Itself in Syria
By Nicholas Heras • Feb 13, 2012
Chaos in Syria
By Ari Katz • Feb 05, 2012
Damascus: Assad's Fortress
By Ayya Harraz • Jan 27, 2012
"Cold War" in West Asia: Asia Pacific Nations Look On
By Zorawar Daulet Singh • Jan 26, 2012
The Need for Intervention in Syria
By Hina Mahmood • Jan 12, 2012

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Post navigation

Previous PostPrevious Images of the Colonial Past and Identity Politics on the Korean Peninsula
Next PostNext India in 2012: Strategic and Security Challenges Beckon
Subscribe
Register for $9.99 per month and become a member today.
Publish
Join our community of more than 2,500 contributors to publish your perspective, share your narrative and shape the global discourse.
Donate
We bring you perspectives from around the world. Help us to inform and educate. Your donation is tax-deductible.

Explore

  • About
  • Authors
  • FO Store
  • FAQs
  • Republish
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Contact

Regions

  • Africa
  • Asia Pacific
  • Central & South Asia
  • Europe
  • Latin America & Caribbean
  • Middle East & North Africa
  • North America

Topics

  • Politics
  • Economics
  • Business
  • Culture
  • Environment
  • Global Change
  • International Security
  • Science

Sections

  • 360°
  • The Interview
  • In-Depth
  • Insight
  • Quick Read
  • Video
  • Podcasts
  • Interactive
  • My Voice

Daily Dispatch


© Fair Observer All rights reserved
We Need Your Consent
We use cookies to give you the best possible experience. Learn more about how we use cookies or edit your cookie preferences. Privacy Policy. My Options I Accept
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Edit Cookie Preferences

The Fair Observer website uses digital cookies so it can collect statistics on how many visitors come to the site, what content is viewed and for how long, and the general location of the computer network of the visitor. These statistics are collected and processed using the Google Analytics service. Fair Observer uses these aggregate statistics from website visits to help improve the content of the website and to provide regular reports to our current and future donors and funding organizations. The type of digital cookie information collected during your visit and any derived data cannot be used or combined with other information to personally identify you. Fair Observer does not use personal data collected from its website for advertising purposes or to market to you.

As a convenience to you, Fair Observer provides buttons that link to popular social media sites, called social sharing buttons, to help you share Fair Observer content and your comments and opinions about it on these social media sites. These social sharing buttons are provided by and are part of these social media sites. They may collect and use personal data as described in their respective policies. Fair Observer does not receive personal data from your use of these social sharing buttons. It is not necessary that you use these buttons to read Fair Observer content or to share on social media.

 
Necessary
Always Enabled

These cookies essential for the website to function.

Analytics

These cookies track our website’s performance and also help us to continuously improve the experience we provide to you.

Performance
Uncategorized

This cookie consists of the word “yes” to enable us to remember your acceptance of the site cookie notification, and prevents it from displaying to you in future.

Preferences
Save & Accept