Political repression in Bahrain is feeding economic and social instability.
The warning signs are clear and unmistakable: The Kingdom of Bahrain is in serious financial difficulty and its economy is tumbling into crisis. The country’s bond ratings are listed as junk. Its gross debt as a percentage of GDP stands at 94.9%, nearly four times the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) average. The IMF has warned that the time is past due for a comprehensive plan to deal with the spiraling debt burden. And Bahrain’s chief benefactors, Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates and Kuwait have hesitated on delivering a comprehensive bailout package until the authorities in Manama can articulate an effective approach to dealing with the economic crisis.
Compounding the challenges facing the kingdom is a political impasse that has persisted for more than seven years. Unique to the Gulf, Bahrain has a Shia Muslim majority ruled for more than two centuries by the Sunni al-Khalifa family. Shia Bahrainis have long complained of discrimination at the hands of the monarchy.
In February 2011, more than 100,000 peaceful protesters — in a country with an indigenous population of a little more than 650,000 — took to the streets and called for democratic reform. Hardliners within the ruling family saw this as a major threat; they had in their minds the role that popular protests had already played in the toppling of dictators in North Africa. Demonstrations in the capital were crushed with lethal force.
In protest, Al-Wefaq, the Shia political bloc in parliament, withdrew its 18 sitting members and in July 2011 pulled out of reconciliation talks altogether. Despite government promises of reform, repression was the order of the day; thousands were arrested, dozens were killed and hundreds more were injured.
As the government crackdown continued, Al-Wefaq responded with a boycott of the 2014 parliamentary elections. The government retaliated by jailing its leader, Shaikh Ali Salman, in 2015. He was sentenced to four years in prison for “inciting hatred, promoting disobedience and insulting public institutions.” In 2016, Al-Wefaq and another political society, Waad, were banned by the government.
There can be no question that the stalemate has severely damaged Bahrain’s economy. It has eroded the many advantages that Bahrain had: a transparent and well-regulated banking system that was attractive to foreign investors; a well-educated youth population committed to an ethos of hard work; a reasonably vibrant private sector; and a society that in contrast to its nearest neighbor, Saudi Arabia, was relaxed and relatively tolerant, including, as it did, Al-Wasat, an independent news site, something unique in the Gulf.
— Bahrain Human Rights (@BahrainRights) June 6, 2018
Today the country is divided deeply along sectarian lines. The majority Shia find themselves living in what amounts to a police state. The ruling family is split between hardliners who want to continue the policy of harsh repression and moderates who see the damage that the impasse has wrought. The trust deficit is huge.
If one accepts that the current situation is unsustainable and unacceptable — and the vast majority of Bahrainis do — and there is acknowledgement that, without a change of direction, the economy will continue in a downward trajectory, then it can be argued that the time is ripe for a move toward common ground that will lead to reconciliation.
The parliamentary elections slated for later this year present an opportunity for that process to begin, but huge obstacles remain in place. The government, at the behest of hardliners, has denied members of banned political societies the opportunity to run in the election. Al-Wefaq remains divided over whether or not, even if it was allowed to field candidates, it would actually do so.
Both sides need to bend a little: the government by dropping its ban that is denying many moderates the opportunity to serve their country at a time of crisis, and the opposition by removing its boycott in order to secure a better deal for the citizens it represents. And, of course, the Shia community which has suffered enormously at the hands of the regime, would need to be persuaded that those among them who chose to run for public office are not betraying the community by doing so. The community would need to make a leap of faith that only its leaders can encourage and support it to take. That task would be made less daunting if the government was to begin the release of political prisoners from Jau Prison, where over 3,000 are currently being held.
Hardliners Have Failed
Granted, Bahrain’s parliament has limited authority and as a result of gerrymandering the opposition does not have any chance of securing enough seats to form a majority. Even so, better in than out. The 2014 boycott gave the hardliners in the ruling family clear ground to argue that the opposition was to blame for the impasse. Emboldened by what amounted to a strategic blunder by those they consider the enemy, they proceeded to crack down even harder, jailing opposition leaders, banning political societies, shuttering Al-Wasat and using the courts, draconian anti-terror legislation and the removal of citizenship in a ruthless bid to crush all domestic opponents.
The hardliners have failed, though, and the failure has not gone unnoticed by the outside world. US Republican Congressman Randy Hultgren, co-chair of the influential Tom Lantos Human Rights Commission, has urged the Bahraini government to “allow its people to organize and express themselves peacefully and according to their own conscience.” Furthermore, “Political repression of the Shia community and free speech advocates and bloggers will not lead to stability, but instead will foster the kind of extremism Bahrain claims to be fighting.”
Above all else, business seeks stability. The congressman makes a simple but utterly valid point — repression in Bahrain feeds instability. It is time for leaders in the Bahraini business community, as well as across the Sunni and Shia communities, to break the impasse and move forward. It is time for moderates in the ruling family to step out of the shadows. The journey toward common ground for reconciliation needs to start now.
*[This article was originally published by Middle East Monitor.]
The views expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect Fair Observer’s editorial policy.
For more than 10 years, Fair Observer has been free, fair and independent. No billionaire owns us, no advertisers control us. We are a reader-supported nonprofit. Unlike many other publications, we keep our content free for readers regardless of where they live or whether they can afford to pay. We have no paywalls and no ads.
In the post-truth era of fake news, echo chambers and filter bubbles, we publish a plurality of perspectives from around the world. Anyone can publish with us, but everyone goes through a rigorous editorial process. So, you get fact-checked, well-reasoned content instead of noise.
We publish 2,500+ voices from 90+ countries. We also conduct education and training programs on subjects ranging from digital media and journalism to writing and critical thinking. This doesn’t come cheap. Servers, editors, trainers and web developers cost money. Please consider supporting us on a regular basis as a recurring donor or a sustaining member.