FO° Talks: Make Sense of Afghanistan With Thomas Barfield: Part 2

World-renowned Afghanistan expert and Boston University professor Thomas Barfield explains how Afghanistan’s democratic government that the US installed became riddled with corruption and failed to attract popular support or win respect.

Check out our comment feature!

Afghanistan is in turmoil. The democratic government installed by the US collapsed after 20 years. This government was a result of a US-led attempt to modernize and reform Afghanistan. However, this Kabul regime lost popular support because of pervasive corruption and fell even before the last US troops left in 2021.

In the first part of this discussion, we talked about the history of Afghanistan’s monarchy. In this second part, Barfield talks about the civil wars that have shaped Afghanistan over the last 50 years.

The communists saw themselves as the successors of the modernizing King Amanullah Khan. After overthrowing President Daoud Khan, they attempted to institute socialism. They found themselves unable, however, to impose order on the country.

Soviet leader Leonid Brezhnev decided to intervene. Despite misgivings, Brezhnev-led Moscow invaded Afghanistan in the hope to clean house and declare victory. The Soviet 1979 invasion turned into a ten-year slog that left one million Afghans dead. When the final Soviet troops left Afghanistan in 1989, they left behind a friendly leader in place. The former Soviet ally Mohammad Najibullah held on till 1992, but the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991 sealed his fate.

Najibullah negotiated a deal with the anti-communist mujahideen rebels. What resulted was a situation where communists and Islamists shared power along ethnic lines, rather than ideological ones. However, warlords soon came to control the country and the country disintegrated into savage civil war.

The chaos destroyed the mujahideen’s reputation as victorious jihadis. The Taliban arose out of the southern city of Kandahar and with Pakistan’s backing took over much of the country, pushing back the warlords. In 2001, the Taliban found its control over Afghanistan threatened because of the September 11, 2001 attacks on New York and Washington, DC.

Because the Taliban would not give up Osama bin Laden to the US, President George W. Bush launched an invasion of Afghanistan. Most of the country sided with the US and troops of the Northern Alliance captured Kabul within a few weeks. 

The US established a democracy but the leaders Washington installed inspired little confidence. Elections occurred but there was little connection between politicians and the people in a country with little tradition of democracy. Assured of US backing, politicians had little to fear and stole the money generously coming from Washington. Misgovernance and corruption were rife. In this strange US-created democracy, politicians did not need popular support and made no attempt to win it.

Within a few years, the people of Afghanistan realized that no reform was in the offing. Presidents behaved like kings, ruling selfishly from palaces in Kabul and siphoning away the foreign aid.

Barfield explains that there are two kinds of corruption. Some leaders use money to buy power. Others, like those in Kabul, used power to buy money. What was left at the end was a state sucked dry of all authority, which enriched a few men who fled the country when their game was up.

Afghanistan: A Cultural and Political History published by the Princeton University Press. You can buy the book here.

[Anton Schauble wrote the first draft of this piece.]

The views expressed in this article/video are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect Fair Observer’s editorial policy.

Comment

FO Talks: Does This Mean the End for Switzerland’s Neutrality?

FO Live: German Economy Now Faces the China Challenge: What Lies Ahead?

October 07, 2026

FO Talks: Trump’s Dangerous New Playbook

October 03, 2026

FO Talks: Drone Warfare and Foreign Meddling in Sudan’s Devastating Civil War

October 02, 2026

FO Talks: Will Historic AfD Victory Now Sink German Chancellor Friedrich Merz?

September 25, 2026

FO Talks: How Viktor Orbán Lost Control of Hungary

September 22, 2026

FO Live: The Red Sea Crisis — Power Struggles in Yemen and Sudan

FO Talks: The Fight For Answers — Investigating Black Deaths

September 16, 2026

FO Talks: Lula vs Another Bolsonaro — Brazil’s 2026 Election

FO Exclusive: The Looming Global Food Crisis — How Hunger and Famine Will Trigger Instability

September 14, 2026

FO Exclusive: Global Economy Teetering on Brink of Major Crisis

September 12, 2026

FO Exclusive: Lightning Roundup of August 2026 Writeup

September 11, 2026

FO Talks: How to Promote Interfaith Unity and Counter Extremism

September 09, 2026

FO Talks: Making Sense of the AI Boom

September 08, 2026

FO Explainers: The Donroe Doctrine — The Future of the Western Hemisphere?

September 07, 2026

FO Talks: Making Sense of the Hidden Gold Mines in e-Waste

September 02, 2026

FO Talks: Making Sense of the NATO Summit

September 01, 2026

FO Talks: AI — Expectation vs Reality

August 30, 2026

FO Talks: Changing Balance of Power in Northeast Asia

August 28, 2026

FO Talks: Make Sense of India’s Youth Cockroach Protests

August 27, 2026

 

Fair Observer, 461 Harbor Blvd, Belmont, CA 94002, USA