FO° Shorts: An Inventor Now Seeks to Turn the Tables on Apple

British inventor Patrick Racz won a lawsuit against Apple in 2013. The company had apparently stolen technology invented by Racz. Since then, Apple has won in higher courts but Racz is appealing against their decisions and still fighting for justice.

Print

“They’ve called me a patent troll but in fact I’m about as far removed from the spectrum as you could possibly get.” So argues British inventor Patrick Racz, who has taken on Apple for copyright infringement. It’s a complex case spanning the past two decades. And it’s taken over his life. But Racz has vowed not to give up.

“They stole my technology and they used it to build the biggest company in the world…. So I will see this through to the end. They’re not going to get away with it.” Remember the days of the iPod, before the iTunes store was invented? That’s when Racz had his lightbulb moment.

A Case of Intellectual Property Theft?

“I’m asked what I invented. I invented particular devices and methods for combining payment functionality, secure downloading, storage and rules for the use of content on portable devices.” In short, Racz invented the backbone of Apple’s iTunes store.

Racz says the problem started when their lead technology partner, a company called Gemplus, “pulled the rug from under our feet” and started claiming the technology as their own. “What I didn’t know at the time was that there were very deep ties and a revolving door between Gemplus and Apple.” The first he knew about Apple using his technology was when it launched its music store in 2003. “That’s when it first got nicked.”

You’d think a patent would have stopped this kind of infringement. But despite applying for a patent back in 1999, it wasn’t granted for a whopping nine years. And by 2008, the genie was out of the bottle.

“I was powerless to do anything,” says Racz. “I had to watch as Apple released product after product after product.” “They took my technology and they created a walled garden. They prevented other device manufacturers from having access to it. And then they taxed everyone at 30%.” It took Racz three years to raise the money to go after Apple.

His company Smartflash filed a lawsuit against Apple in 2013. They went to trial in 2015, and won. “We proved wilful infringement. We proved that Apple stole the technology, we proved that they’d used it extensively.” They also proved that Apple hired a former Gemplus employee as head of digital rights management to implement Racz’s technology. A jury awarded Smartflash $532.9million.

But as Racz puts it, “we just haven’t been paid.”

A Case of Injustice?

Immediately after his victory, Apple released a statement saying that "Smartflash makes no products, has no employees, creates no jobs, has no US presence, and is exploiting our patent system to seek royalties for technology Apple invented. We refused to pay off this company for the ideas our employees spent years innovating and unfortunately we have been left with no choice but to take this fight up through the court system. We rely on the patent system to protect real innovation and this case is one more example of why we feel so strongly Congress should enact meaningful patent reform."

Apple appealed the verdict at both the Patent Trial Appeal Board (PTAB) and the Court of Appeal for the Federal Circuit. This time, it was their turn to win.

“It was rigged,” says Racz. “It transpires that the judges at the Patent Trial Appeal Board were ex-lawyers working for the defendants.” He also claims that the panel of judges at the Court of Appeal for the Federal Circuit was switched at the last minute—to those with close ties to Apple.

“This is no longer a case about patent infringement… It’s about more than that.” “The US patent system has been the subject of regulatory capture. The PTAB is owned, operated and managed by Big Tech. It’s a kangaroo court.”

So where does he go from here? Does he count his losses or double down to fight both Big Tech and the US patents system? You guessed it—both. There isn’t an active case yet but Racz is preparing for more litigation.

Does he ever think about giving up? “Never,” Racz says. “I’ve taken on four of the ten largest companies in the world and the USPTO so you’d think they realize that I don’t give up easily.” He goes on to say: “This is my legacy. And the legacy for my family who’ve suffered through this too. So we’re going to see this through.”

Time will tell if David overcomes Goliath in the 21st century.

The views expressed in this article/video are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect Fair Observer’s editorial policy.

Comment

Leave a comment

FO° Talks: Benny Gantz Goes: Make Sense of Israel’s New Crisis

June 15, 2024

FO° Exclusive: Rishi Sunak Takes Post-Brexit UK to the Polls

June 11, 2024

FO° Exclusive: Iran’s President Falls Out of the Sky

June 06, 2024

FO° Exclusive: Taiwan-China Tensions Increase as New Taiwanese President Takes Charge

June 04, 2024

FO° Talks: Spotlight on Kashmir — When Will We Witness Voter Realignment?

June 03, 2024

FO° Talks: Geopolitical Guru on the State of Indian Democracy, Part 2

June 03, 2024

FO° Talks: Geopolitical Guru on the State of Indian Democracy, Part 1

May 28, 2024

FO° Talks: The ICC Arrest Warrant for Netanyahu Is Devastating

May 24, 2024

FO° Live: Make Sense of the New Israel–Iran Clash

May 21, 2024

FO° Talks: Where Is Ukraine Headed Now? What Does Europe Think?

May 19, 2024

FO° Exclusive: Indian Elections — Mammoth and Unparalleled

May 08, 2024

FO° Exclusive: US Congress Gives Ukraine Sizable, if Not Timely, Aid

May 06, 2024

FO° Exclusive: Conflict in the Middle East Is Now Dangerous

May 04, 2024

FO° Talks: France in Crisis: Macron Now in Bed With Far-Right

April 27, 2024

FO° Talks: Where Is French Immigration Law Heading Now?

March 28, 2024

FO° Talks: Celebrity Culture: More than a Figment of our Imagination

March 24, 2024

FO° Talks: Starvation Now Threatens Millions of Displaced People in Sudan

March 21, 2024

FO° Talks: US Immigration Policy Has Now Reached a Complete Impasse

FO° Talks: Israel’s Invasion of Gaza Will Not Be Over Quickly

February 27, 2024

FO° Talks: Pakistan’s New Election Might Have Been Rigged

February 23, 2024

 

Fair Observer, 461 Harbor Blvd, Belmont, CA 94002, USA