• World
    • Africa
    • Asia Pacific
    • Central & South Asia
    • Europe
    • Latin America & Caribbean
    • Middle East & North Africa
    • North America
  • Coronavirus
  • Politics
    • US Election
    • US politics
    • Donald Trump
    • Brexit
    • European Union
    • India
    • Arab world
  • Economics
    • Finance
    • Eurozone
    • International Trade
  • Business
    • Entrepreneurship
    • Startups
    • Technology
  • Culture
    • Entertainment
    • Music
    • Film
    • Books
    • Travel
  • Environment
    • Climate change
    • Smart cities
    • Green Economy
  • Global Change
    • Education
    • Refugee Crisis
    • International Aid
    • Human Rights
  • International Security
    • ISIS
    • War on Terror
    • North Korea
    • Nuclear Weapons
  • Science
    • Health
  • 360 °
  • The Interview
  • In-Depth
  • Insight
  • Quick Read
  • Video
  • Podcasts
  • Interactive
  • My Voice
  • About
  • FO Store
Sections
  • World
  • Coronavirus
  • US Election
  • Politics
  • Economics
  • Business
  • Culture
  • Sign Up
  • Login
  • Publish

Make Sense of the world

Unique insight from 2,000+ contributors in 80+ Countries

Close

The Problem with Freedom of Speech in Indonesia

By Muhammad Zulfikar Rakhmat • May 09, 2018
Indonesia news, Indonesian news, Islam news, Muslim news, Blasphemy in Islam, Islamic news, Asian news, Asia news, Asia Pacific news, world news

© Leila Ablyazova

Once again, blasphemy has caused a stir in Indonesia — this time over what counts as fiction.

In April, Indonesians were shocked by a statement made by a well-known lecturer in philosophy at the University of Indonesia. In a televised debate, Rocky Gerung said that “Scriptures are fictional and there is still more narration.” The context of Gerung’s statement was related to his defense of the term “fiction,” which can be perceived as negative. Instead, he argued that fiction contains positive messages that have elements of truth.

Gerung’s statement has caused much debate in Indonesia, a religiously conservative country. His comments that link sacred texts to fiction are reckless. Despite being based on his idea that fiction may contain positive connotations, the basis of his statement is weak.

For Muslims, the Quran is a holy and perfect book. It cannot be equated or juxtaposed with anything produced by humans. For example, chapter 10, verse 37 of the Quran states, “And it was not possible for this Quran to be produced by other than Allah, but [it is] a confirmation of what was before it and a detailed explanation of the [former] Scripture, about which there is no doubt, from the Lord of the worlds.”

If we try to link this verse with the statement made by Gerung, a question arises over whether God created a fictional book. For Muslims, the answer is of course not. Muslims believe that the Quran — and, in fact, other Abrahamic scriptures including the Bible and the Torah — is not a fictional account but a divine scripture. There is a separate area of study dedicated to interpreting the meaning of the Quran called tafseer — common to all faiths under different names — and the scholars in this field are certainly not fictional experts.

The fallacy of the link between scripture and fiction can also be seen from the nature of both. Religious scriptures, like the Quran, are seen as absolute by adherents of the faith. The truth contained in them is accepted by Muslims around the world. And the scriptures, like those contained in Surah Yunus (Chapter Jonah), contain definite and binding laws.

In Indonesia, scriptures are also part of the supreme law influencing any state and societal activities. In Pancasila, the official philosophical values of Indonesia, the first principle that states the omnipotence of God also indicates that the country holds firmly to religious scriptures.

The symbolization that links state law and scripture is also seen in every official inauguration in which the holy book is used as a medium to inaugurate government officials. Officials are sworn in with scriptures depending on the faith they follow — an oath just like in the United States. The same is true when people testify in court. Scripture is also used to bind testimony under the umbrella of the law.

The absolute nature of a religious text is inversely proportional to speculative fiction. Although holy books may also contain a story that has not happened yet, such verses are based on absolute trust for adherents of the faith. Conversely, fiction is exactly that: fiction. People would not — and are not expected to — believe that fictional texts are absolute truths. Thus, speculation in fiction cannot be regarded as absolute truth. Ultimately, fiction cannot be a legal foundation.

As a result, religious scriptures cannot be attributed to other traits beyond divinity, even if they are seen as positive. Gerung’s statement is not very different from the blasphemy case brought against Jakarta’s governor, Basuki Tjahaja Purnama, in 2017. Purnama was brought to justice after stating that Muslims had been deluded by a Quranic verse which states that they should not elect non-Muslims leaders during his campaign.

Gerung has to own up to his words and make a public apology to Indonesians. What made the situation worse was that it was uttered in a public setting, not in the academic realm. If a debate takes place between religious leaders and atheists, or in an academia-based religious context, Gerung’s remarks may be acceptable. Unfortunately, his remarks, which were uttered in a conservative country that upholds strict religious laws, were seen by a wide audience.

Public exposure has consequences. As a lecturer at one of the most prestigious academic institutions in the country, Gerung should be fully aware of the effects of his expressed position. His academic capacity will be tested on the robustness of his arguments.

As a student of politics, what I know is that freedom of speech and expression also has limits. To whom we speak, how we speak or when we speak. Because if it doesn’t, the objective of democracy — a peaceful and tolerant society — will not prevail.

The views expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect Fair Observer’s editorial policy.

Photo Credit: Leila Ablyazova / Shutterstock.com

Share Story
CategoriesAsia Pacific, Blog, Culture, World News TagsAsia news, Asia Pacific news, Asian news, Blasphemy in Islam, Indonesia news, Indonesian news, Islam news, Islamic news, Muslim news, world news
Join our network of more than 2,000 contributors to publish your perspective, share your story and shape the global conversation. Become a Fair Observer and help us make sense of the world.

Fair Observer Recommends

India’s Need of the Hour: Organic Fruit Production India’s Need of the Hour: Organic Fruit Production
By Satya Prakash Negi • Sep 30, 2020
India and China: A Time for Diplomacy, Not Confrontation India and China: A Time for Diplomacy, Not Confrontation
By Conn Hallinan • Aug 07, 2020
Will Jokowi’s New Cabinet Bring Change to Indonesia? Will Jokowi’s New Cabinet Bring Change to Indonesia?
By Muhammad Zulfikar Rakhmat, Dimas Permadi & Ramadha Valentine • Oct 28, 2019

Post navigation

Previous PostPrevious The Roots of Europe’s Xenophobia and Radicalism
Next PostNext The Gender Gap in Global Health
Subscribe
Register for $9.99 per month and become a member today.
Publish
Join our community of more than 2,500 contributors to publish your perspective, share your narrative and shape the global discourse.
Donate
We bring you perspectives from around the world. Help us to inform and educate. Your donation is tax-deductible.

Explore

  • About
  • Authors
  • FO Store
  • FAQs
  • Republish
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Contact

Regions

  • Africa
  • Asia Pacific
  • Central & South Asia
  • Europe
  • Latin America & Caribbean
  • Middle East & North Africa
  • North America

Topics

  • Politics
  • Economics
  • Business
  • Culture
  • Environment
  • Global Change
  • International Security
  • Science

Sections

  • 360°
  • The Interview
  • In-Depth
  • Insight
  • Quick Read
  • Video
  • Podcasts
  • Interactive
  • My Voice

Daily Dispatch


© Fair Observer All rights reserved
We Need Your Consent
We use cookies to give you the best possible experience. Learn more about how we use cookies or edit your cookie preferences. Privacy Policy. My Options I Accept
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Edit Cookie Preferences

The Fair Observer website uses digital cookies so it can collect statistics on how many visitors come to the site, what content is viewed and for how long, and the general location of the computer network of the visitor. These statistics are collected and processed using the Google Analytics service. Fair Observer uses these aggregate statistics from website visits to help improve the content of the website and to provide regular reports to our current and future donors and funding organizations. The type of digital cookie information collected during your visit and any derived data cannot be used or combined with other information to personally identify you. Fair Observer does not use personal data collected from its website for advertising purposes or to market to you.

As a convenience to you, Fair Observer provides buttons that link to popular social media sites, called social sharing buttons, to help you share Fair Observer content and your comments and opinions about it on these social media sites. These social sharing buttons are provided by and are part of these social media sites. They may collect and use personal data as described in their respective policies. Fair Observer does not receive personal data from your use of these social sharing buttons. It is not necessary that you use these buttons to read Fair Observer content or to share on social media.

 
Necessary
Always Enabled

These cookies essential for the website to function.

Analytics

These cookies track our website’s performance and also help us to continuously improve the experience we provide to you.

Performance
Uncategorized

This cookie consists of the word “yes” to enable us to remember your acceptance of the site cookie notification, and prevents it from displaying to you in future.

Preferences
Save & Accept