FO° Exclusive: Germany in Spotlight as Russia-Ukraine War Intensifies

Germany is being dragged screaming and kicking into the Russia-Ukraine War. The war is wrecking the economy and causing paroxysm in politics. Germany’s postwar pacifism and its culture of restraint is coming under strain as a center-left coalition dithers about big decisions.

comment badge
Check out our comment feature!
bookmark off

Germany dilly-dallied before parting with 14 Leopard 2 tanks for Ukraine. The reason for such a delay was because Germany was dragged screaming and kicking into the conflict. The zeitenwende—an epochal tectonic shift—that German Chancellor Olaf Scholz spoke about has proved ephemeral.

After speaking to many German politicians and intellectuals, Atul Singh points out that Berlin’s policy is based on three principles:

  1. Support Ukraine as much as possible.
  2. Avoid direct conflict between NATO and Russia.
  3. Avert unilateral action by any single supporting nation.

Simply put, this means that Germany is unwilling to send talks unilaterally. It wants to send its tanks whilst hiding behind the US. Germany is unwilling to be seen as an aggressor by Russia. Berlin wants to minimize the chances of an escalation of conflict with Moscow.

The current center-left coalition has always been more pacifist than its counterparts on the right. The Social Democratic Party of Germany (SPD), the Free Democratic Party (FDP) and Alliance 90/The Greens are in power together. Their traditional colors are red, yellow, and green respectively. Hence, this government is called a traffic light coalition.

Until recently, the SPD championed change through rapprochement. Gerhard Schröder, the last SPD chancellor who was in power from 1998 to 2005, worked for Russian state-owned energy companies, including Nord Stream AG, Rosneft, and Gazprom. The FDP and, especially, the Greens are also peaceniks. Old habits die hard. Germany has a culture of restraint. Singh thinks a U-turn is bound to be difficult.

The Germans were once ruthless jackboot-wearing swashbucklers. Now, they have turned into soft and soggy sissy pants. Once led by authoritarians like Otto von Bismarck and Adolf Hitler, the Germans have swung to extreme consensual coalition politics. Germany has gone from the Führer to incoherence and paralysis.

Singh also points out that the war is not in German or even European economic interest. Industry in Europe relied on cheap Russian gas. With war breaking out in Europe, gas prices have gone up. European industry is withering on the vine. So, it is not in European interest to prolong the war. Hence, support for Ukraine is not in European or German interest. Therefore, this support is likely to wane in the coming months.

Besides, many are making the argument that the Russians are gradually recovering from their early blunders. Initially, they had an intelligence failure, their logistics were ghastly and they carried out a ham-handed version of blitzkrieg. They also lost a lot of senior officers and retreated poorly. Now, they seem to be improving.

Ukraine has a big problem: it is running out of fighting men. Recently, Ukraine lost many members of its top leadership in a helicopter crash. The country is also in the throes of a massive corruption scandal. Since 1991, Ukrainian women have had very few children.  In 2020, the country recorded just 1.22 births per woman. So, Singh believes Ukrainians might just run out of men. The disparate tanks coming from many countries might not be too few and too late to make a difference.

Carle takes the view that Ukraine will not run out of men, Western equipment will eventually make a difference and Russia will suffer increasing strains in 2023. The numbers of Russian tanks are inflated because many are obsolete and/or nonfunctional. Most of Russia’s modern armor has been destroyed. Russia is working its factories around the clock but it is no longer an industrial power and is unable to supply its military with much-needed tanks. This means that the West has a window of opportunity for the next 12 months to put pressure on Russia and help Ukraine achieve victory.

The views expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect Fair Observer’s editorial policy.

Comment

0 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
From MAGA to Gaza How Trump Changed US%E2%80%93Israel Relations Forever FO%C2%B0 Talks

FO° Talks: From MAGA to Gaza: How Trump Changed US–Israel Relations Forever

July 10, 2025
How British Colonialism Impacted India Pakistan Kenya Sri Lanka FO%C2%B0 Talks

Eastminster and Vice-Regalism: How the British Empire Still Shapes Former Colonies

July 09, 2025
This Indian Royalty has 9 World Records Meet Lakshyaraj Singh Mewar Prince of Udaipur FO%C2%B0 Talks

FO° Talks: Meet Lakshyaraj Singh Mewar, Prince of Udaipur

What will the Middle East Look Like if Irans Islamic Regime Falls FO%C2%B0 Exclusive

FO° Exclusive: What Will the Middle East Look Like if Iran’s Islamic Regime Falls?

July 04, 2025
Taking Stock of the DeepSeek Revolution with Sanjay Mittal FO%C2%B0 Talks

FO° Talks: Taking Stock of the DeepSeek Revolution, with Sanjay Mittal

June 25, 2025
The Case for a Responsible Right in the US FO%C2%B0 Talks

FO° Talks: The Case for a Responsible Right in the US

June 20, 2025
The Culture of Culture Part 4 The Sacred Origins of Music FO%C2%B0 Talks

FO° Talks: The Culture of Culture, Part 4: The Sacred Origins of Music

June 15, 2025
The New Strategic Landscape in India%E2%80%93Pakistan Relations FO%C2%B0 Talks

FO° Talks: The New Strategic Landscape in India–Pakistan Relations

June 12, 2025
Make Sense of the Houthis and Civil War in Yemen FO%C2%B0 Live

FO° Live: Make Sense of the Houthis and Civil War in Yemen

GAZA BURNS ISRAEL FRACTURES 1

FO° Exclusive: Hunger Now Strikes Gaza and Big Crisis Brews in Israel

June 04, 2025
DEBT AND DIVISION 1

FO° Exclusive: US Budget and US–China Tariff Deal Unleash New Economic Uncertainty

June 02, 2025
US%E2%80%93Israeli Relations Explained Part 3 Shifting Coalitions FO%C2%B0 Talks

FO° Talks: US–Israeli Relations Explained, Part 3: Shifting Coalitions

May 31, 2025
US%E2%80%93Israeli Relations Explained Part 2 Consequences of the Six Day War FO%C2%B0 Talks

FO° Talks: US–Israeli Relations Explained, Part 2: Consequences of the Six-Day War

May 29, 2025
US%E2%80%93Israeli Relations Explained Part 1 Post World War II FO%C2%B0 Talks

FO° Talks: US–Israeli Relations Explained, Part 1: Post-World War II

May 27, 2025
TERROR 2

FO° Talks: Islamist Terrorist Attack Triggers New India–Pakistan Tensions

May 21, 2025
FRONTLINE INSIGHT 2 2

FO° Talks: An Indian Ringside View of the Russia–Ukraine Conflict

May 20, 2025
ONE REFUGEES FIGHT 1

FO° Talks: A Ukrainian Refugee Reflects on the Russia–Ukraine War

May 17, 2025
DEBT AND DIVISION 2

FO° Talks: Why US Soft Power Is Now Declining Dramatically

May 12, 2025
NASSCOM

FO° Talks: The Story of the Indian IT Industry

May 11, 2025
CAnada

FO° Exclusive: Mark Carney Leads Liberals to a Fourth Consecutive Victory

May 10, 2025

 

Fair Observer, 461 Harbor Blvd, Belmont, CA 94002, USA